Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) as a Treatment for Acute Fear
a study on Fear
Locus coeruleus (LC) norepinephrine (NE) neuron activity has been convincingly linked to regulation of acute fear. This study will address whether LC NE activity examined through pupil measures will reflect carbon dioxide (CO2) induced fear-responses in humans and if transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) can mitigate these effects. A 2 year R21 phase establishing feasibility, tolerability, safety, and proof-of-concept (POC) in terms of capacity to engage LC NE neurons with tDCS, followed by a 3 year R33 parallel-group, double-blind, randomized, controlled trial will determine the degree to which engaging LC NE neurons with tDCS improves clinical symptoms.
The National Institutes of Mental Health (NIMH) has recently identified that a major limitation to the understanding of neuropsychiatric disorders and the development of treatments for these conditions has been the inability to identify key dimensions of observable behavior that are central to these disorders and linked to underlying neurobiology by measurable biomarkers. This project is intended to address this problem by establishing that pupillary measures of norepinephrine (NE) neuronal activity are biomarkers of fear dimension of observable behavior, alterations of which are believed to be core features of neuropsychiatric conditions such as anxiety disorders. The investigators will establish this biomarker-clinical dimension link by comparing pupillary indices in humans to a carbon dioxide (CO2) fear provocation test, as well as in these subjects undergoing transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) prior to and after CO2 administration.
Participants will be recruited in Dr. Krystal's laboratory at Duke University which has proven infrastructure for clinical trials. The study team plans to enroll a total of 240 subjects healthy volunteers (age range: 21-65 years) in order to complete 100. This takes into account the expected rate of failure to: have a pupillary response in the auditory oddball task (AOT) (25%); have a sufficient fear response to CO2 challenge (50% - relevant for last 10 R21 and all R33 subjects); and to meet other screening criteria.
R21 Phase: First 30 Subjects will undergo two sessions separated by 1 week in which a promising electrode configuration (three promising configuration will each be tested in a cohort of 10 subjects) will be used with tDCS stimulation at increasing electrical dosage during which pupillometry will be carried out to determine the auditory oddball test (AOT) response. A maximum of 5 total tDCS dosages and sham will be tested. Last 10 Subjects. These subjects will take part in a double-blind, controlled, randomized, cross-over study over 3 sessions. At session 1 subjects will undergo electrical dose titration with the tDCS electrode configuration resulting from the 3 rounds of optimization using the same procedure as in the first 30 subjects to determine the lowest well-tolerated dose that suppresses the AOT pupil response, except that a maximum of 5 tDCS dosages will be tested at this session. At the third and fourth sessions (1 week apart) subjects will receive dose-optimized tDCS and the control treatment with order randomized along with 7.5% CO2 (to evoke an LC response) for 20 minutes. The 7.5% CO2 will be delivered to us pre-mixed provided by Airgas. At these sessions, the VAS-A and State Trait Anxiety-Inventory (STA-I) will be administered 5 minutes prior to and just after the 20 minute session and Visual Analog Scale-Anxiety (VAS-A) will also be obtained at 5, 10, 15, and 20 minute points of the CO2 inhalation. tDCS will be administered during the last 5 minutes of the 20 minute CO2 inhalation period. Subjects will be monitored for an hour post-session for safety and will undergo study physician assessment to determine suitability to leave. Following the 2nd treatment session participation will end except that subjects will be called the next day to assess for adverse effects and appropriate care will be given if found. R33 Phase: 60 subjects will participate in a double-blind, randomized, controlled, parallel-group trial. They will be randomized to either active or control treatment and at the first post-screening visit they will undergo electrical dose titration as described above for the treatment they are randomized to. For all titrations, during the 5 minutes between tDCS treatments an unblinded member of the study team not having contact with the subjects will compute their AOT pupil response and convey to the tDCS treatment physician whether to continue or stop titration. Subjects randomized to the control treatment will undergo a sham titration where the stop level will be randomly selected from the distribution of titration outcomes occurring in the R21 phase. Subjects will then return in 1 week and undergo optimal dose tDCS or control treatment for a single treatment session as described in the prior paragraph. Primary outcome will be the VAS-A "fearful" rating obtained at the end of tDCS/CO2 inhalation. AOT pupil response will be obtained every 10 minutes after the end of the tDCS/CO2 inhalation period to map the duration of persistent effects on LC. At the end of this session participation will end except that subjects will be called the next day to assess for adverse effects and care given if necessary. Preliminary data from the R21 phase will be used to provide justification for the larger R33 study, and prior to commencing the R33 investigation phase that an addendum to the Institutional Review Board (IRB) protocol with approval will be obtained.
Pupillometry Procedure. The team will employ fully mobile SensoMotoric Instruments (SMI) Eye-tracking Glasses to carry out pupillometry. Pupil diameter will be recorded continuously from the each eye at a sampling rate of 60 Hz via glasses on the subject's face. The investigators will capture pupil size at baseline and in response to the AOT and administration of 7.5% CO2. Data will be segmented into epochs from 0 to 12 s relative to the acquisition onset of each stimuli or experimental condition. An average pupil diameter measure will then be calculated for the corresponding volume by taking the mean across the remaining non-artifactual samples in that epoch. For 7.5% CO2 response the pupil diameter will be averaged over 1 minute periods while subjects are staring at a dark screen in a dark room. This will be computed at baseline, and at 5, 10, 15, and 20 minutes after the start of CO2 inhalation and 5 minutes and 30 minutes postinhalation.
Administration of 7.5% CO2. Inhalation of 7.5% CO2 for 20 min will be carried out. Subjects will be instructed to avoid alcohol for 36 hours and caffeine for 12 hour prior to testing and to eat a light lunch at least one hour prior to testing. A urine pregnancy test will be administered to women of childbearing potential on both days of gas exposure with a negative result needed in order to continue in study participation. Gas will be delivered via a nasal-oral face mask connected via tubing to a 500 L reservoir bag filled with 7.5% CO2/21% Oxygen (O2) 71.5% Nitrogen (N2). Subjects will receive air through the mask in the 10 min prior to CO2 administration during which baseline measures will be obtained.
Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) will be administered with a multichannel direct current stimulation device that can be programmed so that the operator doesn't know the combination of electrodes being used for stimulation, and, thereby allow double-blinding. The active tDCS electrode configuration to be used will be determined with the 3 round iterative procedure described above; based on electric field modeling and personalized electrical dose titration to find the lowest dose that is well-tolerated and engages the target in terms of inhibiting the AOT pupillary response. Electrical dosage will be personalized for each subject by titrating dosage (gradually increasing) until the dosage is found that is both well-tolerated (no more than mild discomfort on a 5-point Likert scale) and suppresses the AOT pupillary response. If the 5-point Likert tolerability rating is greater than "mild discomfort" or if maximum amperage is reached without effect on AOT then subject participation will terminate.
You can join if…
Open to people ages 21–65
- Use of effective method of birth control for women of childbearing capacity
- Willing and able to provide informed consent
- Have a significant difference between the mean pupil diameter in response to odd and common tones in the AOT during screening
- The10 subjects in the R21 cross-over study and all of the R33 subjects must have a 26%increase in VAS-A "fearful" response to 7.5% CO2 at the first CO2 challenge session
- Able to follow study procedures.
You CAN'T join if...
- Current or past Axis I Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM-IV) disorder based on the MINI
- Current or past history of substance abuse or dependence (excluding nicotine) based on history or positive urine toxicology
- Current unstable medical condition
- Any current neurological condition or medical condition that is known to affect pupillary function, mood/anxiety, or neurologic function generally
- Pregnancy based on Urine Pregnancy Test
- Women who are breast‐feeding
- Use of medications known to affect Central Nervous System (CNS) function within 5 half-lives screening
- Use of a pacemaker
- University of California, San Francisco
San Francisco, California, 94143, United States